R v Lewis (1857) Dears & B 182
Report citation: 169 ER 968. Court: Court for Crown Cases Reserved. Decision: 2 May 1857.
The court quashed a manslaughter conviction arising from violence on an American ship. The victim’s subsequent death in Liverpool did not, by itself, bring the homicide within English criminal jurisdiction.
Facts
John Lewis was French by birth and a naturalised citizen of the United States. He and a German seaman, identified in the report as George, joined the American ship Guy Mannering in New York for a voyage to Liverpool. Neither man was a British subject. The ship was American-owned, commanded by an American master and sailed under the United States flag.
Law Teacher writing support
Writing a law essay?
We choose a writer who is an expert in your area of law and qualified to at least the academic level you select. Most of our writers hold a master’s degree or PhD, have teaching experience, or both.
Send us your question and, if you wish, any marking criteria. We’ll write an essay to your instructions.
During the voyage, Lewis and others subjected George to cruelty and violence. The last proved incident occurred on the high seas, west of Cape Clear, four days before the ship reached Liverpool. George died in a Liverpool hospital on 12 January 1857, the day the ship arrived, as a result of the injuries inflicted during the voyage.
Lewis was convicted of manslaughter at Liverpool Assizes. Martin B reserved the question whether the English court had jurisdiction to try and convict him.
The statutory question
The prosecution relied on section 8 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1828. It allowed homicide cases to be tried in England where the fatal injury and death occurred in different places, including an injury inflicted at sea followed by death in England.
Read alone, that provision appeared broad enough to cover Lewis. The question was whether it merely dealt with the place of trial for an offence already within English jurisdiction, or also brought this foreign incident within that jurisdiction because George had died in England.
Judgment
Willes J delivered the court’s judgment. Section 8 was intended to prevent a failure of justice caused by the injury and death occurring in different places. It was not to be read as making a homicide triable in England solely because the victim died there, when the homicide would not have been triable here had death occurred where the injury was inflicted.
Section 7 permitted the trial in England of British subjects for murder or manslaughter committed abroad. Lewis was not a British subject. The fatal violence had been inflicted by one foreigner upon another on a foreign ship on the high seas. If George had died there, the homicide would not have been an offence cognisable by English law in those circumstances.
Section 8 therefore did not sustain the conviction. It was quashed and Lewis was ordered to be discharged. Crompton J agreed with the result but did not endorse the reasoning adopted by the other judges.
Significance
The decision distinguishes a rule addressing where an offence may be tried from a rule establishing jurisdiction over the offence itself. Its conclusion depended on the foreign participants, foreign vessel and location of the violence, together with the scope of the 1828 Act.